Skip to content

Commit c5f3e0c

Browse files
wenshaoclaude
andcommitted
docs: delete item-10 (Ghost Text) — Qwen Code already has it
Qwen Code has: slash completion, @ file completion, shell history, Tab-to-accept follow-up suggestions. The remaining gap (real-time typing prediction) is too small to justify a P1 item. 247 items (was 248), platform sub-report 9 items (was 10). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent c943187 commit c5f3e0c

3 files changed

Lines changed: 3 additions & 34 deletions

File tree

README.md

Lines changed: 2 additions & 2 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -9,7 +9,7 @@
99
| 入口 | 说明 |
1010
|------|------|
1111
| **[Deep-Dive 索引(133 篇)](./docs/comparison/deep-dive-index.md)** | 按主题分类的全部深度分析文章 |
12-
| **[Qwen Code 改进报告(248 项)](./docs/comparison/qwen-code-improvement-report.md)** | Claude Code 对比 + 35 个社区 PR 追踪 |
12+
| **[Qwen Code 改进报告(247 项)](./docs/comparison/qwen-code-improvement-report.md)** | Claude Code 对比 + 35 个社区 PR 追踪 |
1313
| **[Gemini CLI backport(53 项)](./docs/comparison/qwen-code-gemini-upstream-report.md)** | 上游可 backport 改进 + 模块级架构对比 |
1414
| **[/review 功能分析](./docs/comparison/qwen-code-review-improvements.md)** | 审查功能 5 方对比(含 gstack) |
1515
| **[Codex CLI 对标改进(25 项)](./docs/comparison/qwen-code-codex-improvements.md)** | 沙箱 + Apply Patch + Feature Flag + 网络代理 |
@@ -77,7 +77,7 @@
7777

7878
| 报告 | 说明 |
7979
|------|------|
80-
| [Claude Code 对比(248 项)](./docs/comparison/qwen-code-improvement-report.md) | 改进建议 + 35 个社区 PR 追踪(13 已合并) |
80+
| [Claude Code 对比(247 项)](./docs/comparison/qwen-code-improvement-report.md) | 改进建议 + 35 个社区 PR 追踪(13 已合并) |
8181
| [Gemini CLI backport(53 项)](./docs/comparison/qwen-code-gemini-upstream-report.md) | 上游可 backport 改进 + 模块级架构对比 |
8282
| [/review 功能分析](./docs/comparison/qwen-code-review-improvements.md) | 审查功能 5 方对比(含 gstack) |
8383
| [工具输出限高](./docs/comparison/tool-output-height-limiting-deep-dive.md) | Gemini CLI SlicingMaxSizedBox vs Qwen Code |

docs/comparison/qwen-code-improvement-report-p0-p1-platform.md

Lines changed: 0 additions & 30 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -278,33 +278,3 @@
278278
**改进收益**:覆盖 GitLab 用户群——企业级 CI 集成。
279279

280280
---
281-
282-
<a id="item-10"></a>
283-
284-
### 10. Ghost Text 输入补全增强(P1)
285-
286-
**现状**:Qwen Code 已有较完整的输入补全体系:
287-
288-
| 能力 | Qwen Code | Claude Code |
289-
|------|:---------:|:-----------:|
290-
| Slash 命令补全(`/` 触发) |`useSlashCompletion` |`commandSuggestions` |
291-
| @ 文件路径补全(`@` 触发) |`useAtCompletion` |`directoryCompletion` + LRU 缓存 |
292-
| Shell history 补全 |`useShellHistory` |`shellHistoryCompletion` |
293-
| Follow-up 建议(AI 响应后) |`useFollowupSuggestions` |`promptSuggestions` |
294-
| 通用 ghost text(非命令输入时的灰字建议) ||`InlineGhostText` 类型 |
295-
296-
**差距很小**:Qwen Code 的补全体系已较完整——包括 Tab 接受 follow-up 建议(AI 响应后的灰字提示)。与 Claude Code 的差异主要在**用户打字过程中**的实时 ghost text(如输入 `fix` 时预测 `fix the bug in auth.ts`),Qwen Code 的 ghost text 仅在**AI 响应后**(follow-up)和**特定前缀**`/``@`)时触发。
297-
298-
**Claude Code 源码索引**
299-
300-
| 文件 | 关键函数/常量 |
301-
|------|-------------|
302-
| `types/textInputTypes.ts` | `InlineGhostText` 类型定义 |
303-
| `hooks/useTextInput.ts` | ghost text 渲染 + `insertPosition === offset` 检查 |
304-
305-
**实现成本评估**
306-
- 涉及文件:~3 个
307-
- 新增代码:~200 行
308-
- 开发周期:~2 天(1 人)
309-
310-
---

docs/comparison/qwen-code-improvement-report.md

Lines changed: 1 addition & 2 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -55,7 +55,6 @@
5555
| **P1** | GitHub Actions CI — 自动 PR 审查/issue 分类 action [](./qwen-code-improvement-report-p0-p1-platform.md#item-1) | 缺失 |||
5656
| **P1** | GitHub Code Review — 多 Agent自动 PR review + inline 评论 [](./qwen-code-improvement-report-p0-p1-platform.md#item-2) | 缺失 |||
5757
| **P1** | [HTTP Hooks](./http-hooks-deep-dive.md) — Hook 可 POST JSON 到 URL 并接收响应(不仅 shell 命令)[](./qwen-code-improvement-report-p0-p1-platform.md#item-3) | 仅 shell 命令 || [PR#2827](https://github.com/QwenLM/qwen-code/pull/2827) |
58-
| **P1** | [Ghost Text 输入补全](./ghost-text-completion-deep-dive.md) — 输入时显示命令/路径建议灰字,Tab 接受 [](./qwen-code-improvement-report-p0-p1-platform.md#item-10) | 缺失 |||
5958
| **P1** | [Structured Output](./structured-output-deep-dive.md)`--json-schema` 强制 JSON Schema 验证输出 [](./qwen-code-improvement-report-p0-p1-platform.md#item-4) | 缺失 |||
6059
| **P1** | [Agent SDK 增强](./agent-sdk-python-deep-dive.md) — Python SDK + 流式回调 + 工具审批回调(Qwen 仅 TS SDK)[](./qwen-code-improvement-report-p0-p1-platform.md#item-5) | 仅 TypeScript SDK |||
6160
| **P1** | [Bare Mode](./bare-mode-deep-dive.md)`--bare` 跳过所有自动发现,CI/脚本最快启动 [](./qwen-code-improvement-report-p0-p1-platform.md#item-6) | 缺失 |||
@@ -298,7 +297,7 @@
298297
| 文件 | 内容 | 项数 |
299298
|------|------|:----:|
300299
| [P0/P1 核心能力](./qwen-code-improvement-report-p0-p1-core.md) | 上下文压缩、Subagent、Speculation、记忆系统、工具并行、启动优化等 | 13 |
301-
| [P0/P1 平台集成](./qwen-code-improvement-report-p0-p1-platform.md) | GitHub Actions CI、Code Review、SDK、Remote Control Bridge、GitLab 等 | 10 |
300+
| [P0/P1 平台集成](./qwen-code-improvement-report-p0-p1-platform.md) | GitHub Actions CI、Code Review、SDK、Remote Control Bridge、GitLab 等 | 9 |
302301
| [P0/P1 引擎优化](./qwen-code-improvement-report-p0-p1-engine.md) | 流式执行、缓存、Token 管理、崩溃恢复、Agent 编排、上下文管理、安全等 | 27 |
303302
| [P2 核心功能与企业特性](./qwen-code-improvement-report-p2-core.md) | 中等优先级(Shell 安全、MDM 企业策略、Token 计数、Computer Use 等) | 24 |
304303
| [P2 工具与命令](./qwen-code-improvement-report-p2-tools-commands.md) | 中等优先级(Conditional Hooks、/batch、MCP 重连、Ripgrep 回退等) | 20 |

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)