Skip to content

Questions about the number of parameters for the Earth-specific positional bias #64

@15b3

Description

@15b3

Thank you for your excellent research.
I have two questions about the number of parameters for the Earth-specific positional bias.

Screenshot 2024-07-08 at 22-22-00 2211 02556v1 pdf

  1. formula

In the preprint, the formula is given as $(2W_\mathrm{pl}-1)\times2(W_\mathrm{lat}-1)\times(2W_\mathrm{lon}-1)$.
However, I believe the correct formula should be $(2W_\mathrm{pl}-1)\times(2W_\mathrm{lat}-1)\times(2W_\mathrm{lon}-1)$.
Could you please confirm if this is an error or if there is a specific reason for the given formula?

  1. magnification factor

In the first block,

  • $(N_\mathrm{pl}, N_\mathrm{lat}, N_\mathrm{lon}) = (8, 186, 360)$ (186 includes padding).
  • $(W_\mathrm{pl}, W_\mathrm{lat}, W_\mathrm{lon}) = (2, 6, 12)$.
  • Therefore, $(M_\mathrm{pl}, M_\mathrm{lat}, M_\mathrm{lon}) = (4, 31, 30)$.

According to these values, the number of parameters for the former would be:
$(2\times2-1)\times(2\times6-1)\times(2\times12-1) = 759$.
And for the latter:
$4\times31\times2^2\times6^2\times(2\times12-1) = 410,688$.
This results in a ratio of:
$\frac{410,688}{759} \approx 541$.

However, the paper mentions a magnification factor of "$527\times$".
Could you please clarify this discrepancy?

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions